Startmail vs addy.io Comparison (2025)

What are the differences between Startmail and addy.io?

Forward Email Team
Written by
Forward Email TeamVerified
Published
7/1/25
Time to read
Less than 5 minutes
We recommend Forward Email as the best alternative to Startmail.

Email Service Comparison

20 facts in comparison
Startmailvs.addy.io

Startmail

Private email you can trust
"Private email you can trust"
  • Hardenize Test
  • Internet.nl Site Test
  • Internet.nl Mail Test
  • Mozilla HTTP Observatory Grade
  • Qualys SSL Labs SSL Server Test
vs.

addy.io

Protect your real email address using email aliases
"Protect your real email address using email aliases"
  • Hardenize Test
  • Internet.nl Site Test
  • Internet.nl Mail Test
  • Mozilla HTTP Observatory Grade
  • Qualys SSL Labs SSL Server Test
$7/moPricing$4/mo
20 GBStorageNo addy.io does not support storage
25 MBAttachments25 MB
NoOpen-SourceYes
❌ Startmail claims to use a User Vault, but this statement has not been audited and their source code is closed-sourceSandboxed Encryption No
NoUnlimited DomainsNo
NoUnlimited AliasesYes
NoTTI No
YesSMTPNo
YesIMAPNo
YesPOP3No
NoAPINo
⚠️ Supported if both sender and recipient are using OpenPGPE2EE No
⚠️ Supports OpenPGP, but does not support WKDOpenPGP No
NoWKD No

Email Service Screenshots

Closed-source

Startmail

Startmail is a closed-source email service. Their website says: Private email you can trust

Startmail is a closed-source email service.
Photograph by Forward Email
Visit Website
Open-source

addy.io

addy.io is an open-source email service. Their official description reads: Protect your real email address using email aliases

addy.io is an open-source email service.
Screenshot by Forward Email
Visit Website

Compare Startmail with 78 email services